Saturday 7 October 2023

Mauvin Godinho is the biggest beneficiary of “Extra Democracy” -- By Nisser Dias

Mauvin Godinho's assertion that Goa has an "Extra Democracy" appears to be rooted in an attitude of arrogance and superiority. He even went so far as to draw a parallel with China, implying a desire for absolute power. Such comparisons to China's communist government suggest a concerning aspiration for unchecked authority.

It is essential to remember that democracy, as defined by the 16th American President Abraham Lincoln, is "Government of the people, by the people, for the people." Mauvin's comments were aimed at the people who were voicing objections to various government projects that seemed to run counter to the wishes of the Goan populace. These frustrations are understandable, given that many of these projects often prioritize the interests of those in power over the well-being of the Goan citizens.

However, it is ironic that Mauvin Godinho himself is arguably the biggest beneficiary of this so-called "Extra Democracy." In 1998, he faced allegations of corruption when he served as the power minister in the Congress government, accused of involvement in a power rebate scam amounting to Rs. 4.52 crore. Despite these allegations, he was not only allowed to join the BJP but also became a minister within the same party. This raises questions about the true nature of democracy, as such preferential treatment appears to be a case of "Extra Democracy."

Furthermore, the fact that the charges against him were eventually reduced to just the power rebate scam highlights the issue of "Extra Democracy" even further. The ongoing criminal trial after 25 years also raises concerns about the efficiency and fairness of the government.

Mauvin Godinho has consistently been elected from Cortalim and Dabolim constituencies. During his tenure, the Sancoale communidade has seen the encroachment of migrants, which suggests political involvement and patronage. It is widely known that Mauvin prioritizes his significant migrant vote bank over the concerns of Goan citizens, further illustrating the concept of "Extra Democracy" from which he has benefited.

Nonetheless, it is crucial for Mauvin Godinho to remember the essence of true democracy. Democracy revolves around empowering the people as the ultimate decision-makers. Over time, it has evolved to encompass principles such as equality, political accountability, citizens' rights, and, to some extent, the values of liberty and justice.

In a democracy, the ultimate authority to deliberate and determine the country's legislation rests with the people, either directly or through their elected representatives. Thus, criticizing activists and NGOs for raising their voices against projects that are detrimental to the people or the environment and pushing the government to reconsider destructive initiatives is not an "Extra Democracy" but a fundamental right.

On the other hand, it is unfortunate that India's democratic values have been eroding since 2014, when the BJP government assumed power. Challenges to freedom of speech, minority rights, increased pressure on human rights groups, intimidation of journalists and activists, and a surge in attacks against minorities, particularly Muslims, have all contributed to a decline in political and civil liberties. This shift has intensified the discussion about the preservation of democracy and its core principles in public discourse.

No comments:

Post a Comment