Until five years back, Goans had been finding
an easy way out for better quality of life and that was gate-crashing into
England via Portugal. The Portuguese have been kind enough to allow Goans into
its country as a goodwill gesture for making it their colony four centuries
back.
There was no issue at all even though lakhs
of Goans had opted for Portuguese passport with different perception. The main
being employment and better quality of life. Of course there was a hitch there
that nobody realised. And that is after acquiring Portuguese passport, one
could not work for the Goan government as the person becomes a foreigner in his
own motherland.
Individuals with government employment in Goa
undertook this exercise of opting for Portuguese citizenship while working for
the government here, to facilitate their children to acquire the Portuguese
passport and migrate to Europe for job opportunities were meagre here and also
very less paying for the type of talent and educational qualification our youth
have achieved.
Everything was fine till the time politicians
muddled the issue for their own benefit. The very first instance was when
defeated Benaulim candidate Valanka Alemao daughter of Churchill Alemao raked
up Caitu D’silva’s nationality as Portuguese citizens simply because he won the
2012 Assembly elections against her. In turn Caitu unearthed Churchill Alemao’s
nationality. Sadly both the cases are gathering dust in the courts of Law in
Goa.
To add fuel to fire, Nuvem MLA Mickky Pacheco
who had an axe to grind with Superintendent of Police Allan D’sa produced
documents indicating that the latter was a foreigner working as a high ranking
police officer in Goa.
Mickky had an axe to grind against D’sa as he
refused to dance to the Legislators tune and had put Nuvem MLA’s pet police
inspector Edwin Colaco on a tight leash.
As SP D’sa was battling the controversy, one
RTI activists produced documents showing that PI Edwin Colaco had also
registered his birth in Portugal. With this the can of worms finally spilled
out. Large number of government servants in all its departments had registered
their birth in Portugal. Some to settle in Portugal or England after
superannuation or to facilitate their children to secure gainful employment in
these countries.
Union government realized it and maintained a
status quo. However it was upon the Judiciary to interpret and decide, whether
mere registering birth or thereafter marriage amounted to being a Portuguese
citizen. The Indian judiciary was found wanting in this matter.
Very soon Caitu D’silva who was elected as
Benaulim MLA will complete his term of five years but the judiciary is still saddled
with the matter. After his term is over Valanka Alemao’s case against Caitu
becomes infractuous as she had demanded that he be disqualified for obtaining
‘Bilhete de Indentidade’ and ‘Cartao de Cidadao’.
It will be a different issue altogether if he
tries to contest election again as all those who have registered their birth
and marriage in Portugal will have to show their Indian citizenship and not
origin of birth.
It was the sole responsibility of the
Judiciary to decide whether just obtaining ‘Bilhete de Indentidade’ and ‘Cartao
de Cidadao’, amounts to being a foreigner in his country of birth or origin.
This is still being debated and the answer to this complex issue still fluttering
in the wilderness.
Then came along Remo Fernandes, Goa’s prized
political singer besides tiartists and 2012 Assembly Election mascot. Till this
very year, Remo was kept on high pedestal by Goans of every hue. Fearless
social activists, corruption crusader and one man army against the government
advocate Aires Rodrigues, who sought out International pop star in his
crosshair for allegedly abusing and threatening a minor girl over whom his
(Remo’s) son had driven his car. As the debate over Remo’s visiting the girl in
Goa Medical College was raging, adv. Aires dropped a bomb that stunned most
Goans. He claimed that Remo Fernandes had attained Portuguese citizenship and
that he was no longer a Goan.
From here on the war became murkier with one
advocate from Margao Rajeev Gomes representing Remo claimed that his learned
colleague Aires Rodrigues was also a Portuguese citizen and had also stayed in
Portuguese way back in 1987 and that his birth and marriage was also registered
in Portugal. An FIR was lodged against Aires by controversial Colva panch
member Calvert Gonsalves who is also being represented by adv. Gomes. Allegedly
this duo adv. Rajeev and Calvert have even lodged a complaint with the Bar
Council of Maharashtra to suspend Aires license to practice Law in Goa.
Not a person to take things lying down, adv.
Aires posted documents to indicate that adv. Rajeev Gomes had his birth also
registered in Portugal in 2010 along with that of his son. Subsequently, an FIR
under Citizenship Act was also registered against Rajeev
This was the pits when two advocates get
personal and point fingers at each other over Portuguese citizenship. One could
argue that layman working in government service did not realize the implication
of obtaining Portuguese passport but can the advocates be excused for being
ignorant the law or were they transgressing, contravening or flaunting the Law
to continue practicing in Goa.
This ugly duel brought to the fore some
sought of stigma attached to procuring or obtaining Portuguese passport. If an
individual ups his ante against the government or local self bodies or that
matter against any wrong-doing, immediately his citizenship is scrutinized to
find out whether he has attained Portuguese nationality. If so the protesting
Goans is targeted and branded as being a foreigner is his own land.
Acquiring, procuring and obtaining Portuguese
citizenship by Goans is merely a matter of compulsion for better quality of
life and job opportunities but it does not mean that all the Goan who have
opted for Portugal citizenship have lost their love for Goa. Deep in the
recesses of heart they still love Goa but circumstances have forced them to
change their nationality.